I've had these boots for about a month and I really like them. The leather is durable and the canvas sides provide a nice contrast. I really like the leather sole, it gives these boots a unique touch. They look great with jeans or slacks/khakis, especially if you shine them up a bit (see below for an explanation). I bought a 13 and they do feel like they're half a size too big, but overall they are very comfortable. Just make sure you wear socks that go up past the top of the boot. I wore a pair of ankle-length socks in a pinch and the top of the boot rubbed a nice raw spot above my Achilles. One negative about the look (for me personally) is that they are apparently intended to look like they're been worn during winter. This is because the leather and canvas have grayish-white areas that look like it's faded/covered faux salt. You can see it in the close up pictures. This looks fine with jeans, but if you are wearing these with slacks I suggest touching the leather and canvas areas up with some Kiwi touch-up shine or similar. This will cover the salty look without making the leather look too shiny. Overall I give these boots an A and would definitely buy another pair.