This is a beautiful shoe and I love that it has no platform. The toe is not too pointy and not too round. I would have given it 5 stars if it wasn't at least 1/2 size too big (long). It is also a bit narrow in the toe area, but that is the style of the shoe, and it has stretch slightly. I added foot petals to the area where the ball of my foot hits and it helped with comfort. But it is still a 4-inch heel...so it can only be so comfortable. I would definitely recommend this shoe for someone needing a classic, never-out-of-style black pump.

These are beautiful shoes, and look more expensive than they are. The red suede is a gorgeous color. However, my usual size (9.5) was so large I walked out of them. I returned these for a size 9, and these were too small in the toe area. I may try a 9.5 again and use heel and toe pads to make them fit.