I love, love LOVE this boot!!! They have not come off since I received them about a week ago. They look great with leggings and skirts and look fantastic with jeans. I have about a 16.5 calf, and these boots work for me. The tongue is wide enough to really loosen up the tops. I wear them over thick leggings with nice mid-weight socks just fine. I have not tried them over jeans, but I'm not super
keen on that look anyway. My only complaint, and it's a minor one, for me anyway, is that when I walk on graveled trails, and I do often, I can feel the gravel under my feet. I think that's due to the soles being so flexible. The snow has not hit yet, so I can't attest to how waterproof they are. But I have no doubt they will
keep me cozy and dry when it dose.