This shoe is awesome. The material itself is water resistant, but obviously if you submerge them you are going to get water in them. Personally, I didn't expect them to
keep my feet dry underwater, apparently some people did. Anyhow, the biggest selling point for me was the style. They look like regular
shoes. Most water
shoes are absolutely hideous. I have received many compliments on these. I found them to be very comfortable and do exactly what a water shoe should. They drain and dry quickly and designed specifically for water use. At first, slipping in and out was tough, but the broke in after a few times in the water and it's no problem after that. Basically, they are like a water sock which you slip on, but with laces to cinch them down and styling to disguise them as regular
shoes. Unfortunately, I
lost one camping, but I just reordered a new pair. I won't lose them again.