Wow, I don't usually write a review for the shoes I buy, but I just had to for these. These are the most amazing boots I have ever purchased! I was deciding between these and 4 other styles of Fryes and once they all arrived in the mail (a day later - I love you, Zappos), these won hands down. Yes, they are pricey, but so worth it. The leather is amazing, the detailing rocks - these boots are such high quality, you won't believe it. The calf circumference is slightly smaller than you might be used to, but will be perfect for those of you out there who find most knee boots to be overwhelming on your leg. Buy them - you won't be disappointed!

Quality of these boots are excellent! Yes, they're pricy, but I'm hoping they'll last me for years to come. The sole is comfy and these boots run true to size, my only beef is that I wish these boots had a side zipper. Also, since I'm planning to tuck jeans into these boots and I'm an average sized girl, I dare not gain any weight because the boot shaft is a little snug! Overall, awesome boots.

Love Quality and Comfort - These boots are extremely well-made, of exquisite quality, and feel great. They are pricey but worth it as they are a definite notch above most of the boots I have seen out there, and worth the cost. They seem a little tight at first but break in within the first hour and get very comfortable. They look hot!!

I've been salivating over these Frye Caroline Campus boots - My husband surprised me with this purchase. My heart skipped a beat! Anyway - the design is cool, the heel is just the right height, leather is high quality, the stitching looks good, construction is solid. However, I can't get my foot in the bed of the boot. They are pull ons and I couldn't get my heel in at all. I suspect I would need a whole size larger. Bummer! I will send these back; I may try a bigger size, but I may try a side zip pair. Thanks to Zappos!

Love this shoe, I got both colors. I have a narrow foot and the extra padding made them fit like they were custom made for me...and I might add that I am 67 years old and can walk in them all day. Love the lighter color.

I agree with other reviewers: the toe box of this shoe is tight in comparison to the rest of the shoe. I usually wear a size 5.5 in most shoes, I ordered a 5.5 and 6 based on other reviewers saying that a half size up from what they usually wear ended up fitting better. The toe box on the size 6 was perfect but the rest of the shoe was too big. The 5.5 fit well everywhere except the toe box, which was far too tight. There was a fair amount of toe cleavage with both pairs, which I don't care for. It's too bad neither size was right for me because I love the color and overall style, plus the padding inside is heavenly!

Love the shoe style. However, the toes were so scrunched...mind you I have a size 5 narrow foot!

These are the most comfortable high heels I have ever had on my feet. I am over sixty and had given up on heels. I had go so far as to give them away. I am back!

These shoes are absolutely gorgeous. I haven't worn heels higher than 2" in about 10 years and these are the most comfortable shoes ever. They are so well padded, I feel like I'm "gelling" all day. They are even more cushioned than gel insoles. I ordered my regular size 9m, and they were too small. I went up a half size (9 1/2m) and they fit perfectly. I purchased the blush, and it is a very pretty color. However, the color is too light for my dark toned legs - so, I am waiting for the black. I wish they came in a taupe. Really great shoes.