Too clunky and strange angle at the upper part. They get wider at the top and are not very flattering. Very nice quality but not for me.

OMG. I finally found a boot I am going to keep! Thank you Zappos for your patience with me. This Lucky Brand Aid boot must be new because there were no reviews yet. I took a chance and ordered them. They are the fifth pair I have tried after striking out with the Frye Veronica shortie (tight toe box), the Dr. Marten Meg (impossible to get on, tho cute), Gentle Souls Buckle Up (gorgeous but just a little too high and maybe too fancy for what I wanted. Plus I didn't love the zipper. I prefer pull-on styles). There were a couple more but you get the idea. These Lucky's are lightweight, quiet when I walk, and look almost identical to my Frye Engineer 12's which I absolutely love (but find them a little heavy for schleppin' around in all day). They are also almost half the price! If you are between sizes, I'd order up. I usually wear a 7 or 7.5. I ordered a 7.5 and they are good. The toe is slightly snug but it feels like they will give. Not a lot of arch support, but not terrible. I tried my SuperFeet in and they are too tight with those. I might try the lower profile super feet, as that might work. Highly recommend