I originally ordered the Baffin
Whitetail. The fit, size wise, was good, but the height of the boot tops cut me right across the ankles and were very uncomfortable, almost
painful. I asked to return them and ordered the Baffin
Lynx at the same price. They are basically the same shoe, but the Lynx is more of a shoe than a short boot like the Whitetail is. They fit great and are very comfortable, and keep
my feet warm and dry. They fit true to size for a size 9, but I wish Baffin
had half sizes available, as the size 9 is a little big for me, I think a 8-1/2 would be perfect. But with heavy socks, the size 9 works fine. They aren't the most stylish shoes
, but for what they are - a foul weather shoe - I'm very happy with them and very happy with Zappos' excellent customer service and easy return policy.