Posted: 2011-12-23 08:14:33
Reviewer: Tim Z from Harrisburg, PA
Overall: 
Comfort: 
Style:
This is a terrific high quality shoe. It's very well made with nice detailing. It has a retro look that goes with jeans or a suit or anything in-between. I normally wear a size ten, but had to reorder this shoe in a 9.5.
Posted: 2012-01-13 21:42:07
Reviewer: Anonymous from San Antonio, TX
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
This is awesome pair of
shoes. I wear them to work with basic twill pants. They look great and are comfortable.
Posted: 2012-01-12 16:53:14
Reviewer: Nick B from Cincinnati, OH
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
The Gaffney has been my go to pair of boots for the last month. Every time I put them on I get compliments for total strangers. I've worn them to work a few times and they offer a good amount of comfort throughout the day. These have earned themselves a permanent spot in my weekly shoe rotation.
Posted: 2011-10-21 05:24:18
Reviewer: Oleg G
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I love it. Comfy and stylish.
Posted: 2011-10-11 09:35:28
Reviewer: Melvin W from New Jersey
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
Very Good Boot. Looks good and fits well.
Posted: 2011-09-01 23:20:56
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I am loving these boots! They have style, the chestnut leather is really nice and the comfort is great right out of the box. These are going to be one of my staple casual and dressed up, but not formal, fall/winter/spring shoe of mine. Two other reviews mark these as running a full size larger. For me it is just half a size larger than marked. I am a true 10½ but due to the other reviews I ordered smaller sizes. I bought both 9½ and 10 just to be on the safe side. I am glad I did because the size 10 is perfect and 9½ is uncomfortably tight. The 9½ hurt my heel while walking and felt tight all around.
Posted: 2011-08-26 21:09:49
Reviewer: Anonymous from Western Massachusetts
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I purchased the Blue Suede Boots. I normally wear a 13, had to go down a size. Perfect fit in a 12. Soft suede and shaped to my foot quickly very comfortable to wear. I love these
shoes. Sharp Wing tip dress shoe meets boot. Looks awesome with jeans.
Posted: 2012-02-27 16:16:48
Reviewer: David M from North
Carolina
Overall:
Comfort: 
Style:
A very nice looking shoe that takes a while to break in. Very Downton Abbey. Traction is good to excellent on most textured surfaces but slippery on smoother ones. The soles are hard rubber-like treads, good for tramping around the countryside but kind of jarring on pavement. One heel is coming off already after wearing just a few times but that could be just a fluke. A little glue and they should be okay for the next five years or so.
Posted: 2011-10-03 17:18:10
Reviewer: S B from New York City
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
I originally bought these in a black size 10 and as everyone has said they do run large so I then bought a 9.5 and they fit perfectly, but then the first time I wore them the heel fell off! I really loved the way these boots looked so wanted to order them again even though the quality is now in question for sure, they still look expensive. Well black in a 9.5 was now sold out so I got them in chestnut leather. So glad I did the chestnut looks even more expensive yet more casual. I really love the way they look and feel and hope they last a long time (crossing my fingers though).
Posted: 2011-08-17 14:12:06
Reviewer: Ryan from Atlanta
Overall:
Comfort:
Style:
These are great, although my normal size felt humongous. A little hard to put on, but I'm sure over time that will get better. Very nice shoe.
