Received a defective shoe but liked otherwise - I liked this shoe, but unfortunately one of the ones I received had a defect and I had to send it back. I would've kept it otherwise. It comes with a pair of lighter laces, which I also liked, to make the shoe less uniform in color. I like the squarish shape of these shoes, as they are more accurately foot-shaped than most shoes and fit my foot naturally. I wish more shoes were shaped like this.

Great Casual Shoe - This shoe is just what I was looking for. Casual comfort but not a granny shoe.

Nice but flawed - Loved these when I first received them. They are comfortable, fairly warm, soft. But the top flops way down, no matter how tightly I tie them. It is a pain and it looks bad. Sometimes only one does and it looks even worse. It is definitely a design flaw--the tie loops need to be higher.

OK - These boots are so warm (the black leather ones)! But they come untied; I have to use a double knot. Appearance-wise, I feel they are just ok. They felt true to size- I ordered up based on the reviews and had to exchange them.

Beautiful! Ordered a half size larger in length and wide (D) width as recommended in reviews. I also ordered in both red and khaki (really a lovely deep olive color) to see which color I liked better. I choose the red and a friend fell in love with the khaki. These feel like moccasins and are nice and warm. I might add inserts as my feet like a lot of cushioning. Easy to tuck in jeans, etc. due to flap construction. I am very glad to have found this boot.

Too small - Beautiful boot, but alas, much too small for my foot, I ordered my regular size. Had to send back.

Camper Industrial - I really did like this boot. It was comfortable, warm, good-looking, and fit well. About the only thing that could have improved it is more lining on the bottom of the boot. I like my foot to be wrapped in the plush lining and there was none. I also thought the way the boot looked when it was laced was very cute. I have one complaint. Why do companies list red as a color when the color is NOT red? It's actually rust. Red is not a generic name for any shade that happens to be close to it. I really wish, and it's not just Zappos, that companies would describe the shade of the color. I've been looking for a red boot now for a long time, and with my wide feet, it's been very hard. I really hoped this one would be red. I ordered size 8 (I wear a 7) because this doesn't come in a wide, and the fit was pretty good. In fact, the length was a tad too long, but the width was fine. If this had been a true red color, I wouldn't have minded paying the rather high price tag, but I have returned them, and will keep searching. Please, please, describe colors!